The Meanings of Imagine Part II: Attitude and Action

 Judentum

 15 views
of 14
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Description
I investigate, in Part II, different approaches to the question of what makes imagining different from belief. I find that the sentiment-based approach of David Hume falls short, as does the teleological approach, once advocated by David Velleman. I
Share
Tags
Transcript
   " !"# %#&'(')* +, -./&)('#0 1&23 ..4 533(367# &'7 583(+' #$%&'()*+,)%- .*&,( *& !"#$%&%'"( *%+',&& /#""01 2/"3456 765"89- $(%,:% ;*)% .*&,(0 9#(: ;&' <##6=#' < ;(,=*.*%>1 *& ?,=) <1 >*..%=%&) :%&:%: @. A*+,B*&%C ,&> A*+,B*&,)*@&DC E,;F F,: , -%.&/01-/#23 :%&:%1 ,& ,//#/143 :%&:%1 ,&> ,& #+,5#&/#- :%&:%D "  < )F%& ,:G%> , H'%:)*@& ;@&;%=&*&B *+,B*&*&B: @. ,&I :@=)1 (*G% )F% >=,B@& *+,B*&*&B I@' +,I F,J% F,> *& =%:$@&:% )@ +I $=@+$)K "D  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 '03&1''%&34   *& )F% ,&:M%= M% U':) B,J% )@ )F% .*=:) H'%:)*@&D V. ,))*)'>% *+,B*&*&B:K 6D   WF,) ,=% )F%*= )I$*;,( ;F,=,;)%=*:)*;: J*%M%> :I&;F=@&*;,((I1 *&;('>*&B @&%: )F,) :%$,=,)% )F%+ .=@+ =%(,)%> :),)%:1 (*G% O%(*%. ,&> $%=;%$)*@&N 6  X&> @&;% M% ;@&:*>%= )F*: H'%:)*@& ;,=%.'((I1 M%Y(( O% *& , $@:*)*@& )@ ,:G @'= )F*=> H'%:)*@&1 ,(:@ .@;':%> @& ,))*)'>% *+,B*&*&B:K ZD   WF,) ,=% )F%*= >@M&:)=%,+ ;@&:%H'%&;%: @& %+@)*@& ,&> ,;)*@&1 %:$%;*,((I $=%)%&:% #@= +,839:3$#323 0N Q@ @'=  7%-#  .@= ?,=) << ,=% ,))*)'>%: ,&> ,;)*@&D S') O%I@&> U':) >*:;'::*&B J,=*@': $@::*O(% ,&:M%=: )@ 6 ,&> Z1 < M,&) )@ B*J% , :%&:% @. U':) F@M >*..*;'() )F%:% H'%:)*@&: ,=%D X) )F% )*+% @. M=*)*&B1 )F%=% *: &@ ;(%,= ;@&:%&:': ,&:M%= )@ MF,) >*..%=%&)*,)%: *+,B*&*&B .=@+ O%(*%.D [@= *: )F%=% , ;@&:%&:': ,O@') F@M *+,B*&*&B: ,=% *+$(*;,)%> *& )F% B%&%=,)*@& @. ,;)*@&D Q@ < F@$%1 ,O@J% ,((1 )@ ;@&J%I , :%&:% @. )F% $F*(@:@$F*;,( *&)%=%:) *&F%=%&) *& O@)F H'%:)*@&:D "  Q%% ?,=) < #65"Z0 .@= .'=)F%= ;(,=*.*;,)*@&D   6  \@= =%,:@&: @. :$,;%1 )F% $=%:%&) ?,=) M*(( .@;': @& )F% ;@&)=,:) O%)M%%& ,))*)'>% *+,B*&*&B ,&> O%(*%.D < >@ )F*&G1 F@M%J%=1 )F,) )F% ,&)*3:I++%)=I ;(,*+ < >%J%(@$ F%=% ;,& O% %])%&>%> #M*)F +@>*.*;,)*@&:0 )@ )F% =%(,)*@& O%)M%%& $%=;%$)*@& ,&> *+,B%=ID   6 !"# 12+>:#/4 ?"&3@* 3"# 7(,,#2#'8# >#3=##' >#:(#A(') &'7 (/&)('(')B ^%;,(( )F,) M%Y=% .@;':%> @& ,//#/143& 1 @= MF,) < ;,(( ,//#/143 #+,5#.#.5 - )F,) *:1 , ;@B&*)*J% ,))*)'>% )F,) F,: $=@$@:*)*@&,( ;@&)%&)D R@&:*>%= )F% .@((@M*&B ;@&)=,:):D #"0   S%)F :3$#323&  *) M*(( :&@M )@+@==@MD #60   <,& #+,5#.3& ;7#-/#%.,$$(<  *) M*(( :&@M )@+@==@MD #Z0   X(J*& ,&&1+3& 7%0 /"3 &,83 %7 ,051+3./   *) M*(( :&@M )@+@==@MD #80   L%,)F%= "('%/"3&#=3&  *) M*(( :&@M )@+@==@MD PF% >*+%&:*@& @. J,=*,)*@& F%=%_,:*>% .=@+ )F% ,B%&): )F%+:%(J%:_*: MF,) M% ;,(( ,//#/143 1 ,: < $@*&)%> @') *& ?,=) <D PF% ;@&)%&): @. )F% +%&),( :),)%: '&>%= ;@&:*>%=,)*@& ,=% ,(( )F% :,+%1 ,: #M% +,I $=%:'+%0 ,=% )F% :)=';)'=%: @. )F% *&)%=&,( =%$=%:%&),)*@&: *& MF*;F )F% ;@&)%&): ,=% %&;@>%>D V&(I )F% ,))*)'>%: ,=% >*..%=%&)D [@M .@;': @& #"0 ,&> #60D V'= ),:G *: )@ ;F,=,;)%=*`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 *: &%*)F%= &%;%::,=I &@= :'..*;*%&) )@ )'=& ,& *+,B*&*&B *&)@ , O%(*%.D V&% +*BF) ,$$(I :';F , &@=+ )@ :@+% @. F%= *+,B*&*&B:1 )=I*&B @&(I )@ *+,B*&% )F,) .@= MF*;F )F%=% *: :@+% %J*>%&;% @. )=')F1 M*)F@') )F%=%OI +,G*&B )F% *+,B*&*&B: *&)@ O%(*%.:- ,&> @&% +*BF)1 @') @. ,>F%=%&;% )@ $=,B+,)*:+1 =%.':% )@ ,$$(I :';F , &@=+ )@ @&%Y: O%(*%.:1 M*)F@') )F%=%OI +,G*&B )F%+ ,&I (%:: O%(*%.:D Q@ *. Q*&F,O,O'Y: ,=B'+%&),)*@& *: =*BF)1 )F% H'%:)*@& O%;@+%: %J%& +@=% $=%::*&BK MF,) 4%3&  >*:)*&B'*:F O%(*%. .=@+ *+,B*&*&BN Q*&;% ,&:M%=*&B )F*: H'%:)*@& *: ;%&)=,( )@ @'= $=%:%&) ;@&;%=& @. '&>%=:),&>*&B ,))*)'>% *+,B*&*&B: B%&%=,((I1 <Y(( >*:;':: )F=%% ,$$=@,;F%: )@ *)K )F% :%&)*+%&)3O,:%> #@= $F%&@+%&@(@B*;,(0 ,$$=@,;F :'BB%:)%> OI a,J*> L'+%1 )F% )%(%@(@B*;,( ,$$=@,;F @. a,J*> b%((%+,&1 ,&> )F% *&.%=%&)*,(*:) ,$$=@,;F :'BB%:)%> OI Q*&F,O,O' ,&> @)F%=:D <) M*(( )'=& @') )F,) ,& *&.%=%&)*,(*:) J*%M +*BF) U':) M@=G1 O') &@) H'*)% *& )F% .@=+ Q*&F,O,O' $=%:%&): *)- *.1 F@M%J%=1 M% +@>*.I Q*&F,O,O'Y: J*%M *& )F% =*BF) M,I1 M%Y(( F,J% , J*,O(% ;,&>*>,)% ,&:M%=D <& ,&I ;,:%1 M% :F@'(> G%%$ *& +*&> )F,) )F*: *: :)*(( ,& @$%& H'%:)*@&1 @& MF*;F +@=% M@=G :F@'(> O% >@&%D Z   Z  PF%=% ,=% ,$$=@,;F%: )@ )F*: $=@O(%+ )F,) < >@&Y) F,J% :$,;% F%=% )@ >*:;':: .'((ID c;T*&& #65581 $$D "64 ..D01 .@= %],+$(%1 ),(G: ,O@') A;@B&*)*J% *+,B*&,)*@&C ,&> ;(,*+: A*+,B*&*&B )F,) $ *: ,& ,;)*@&1 MF*(% O%(*%J*&B )F,) $ *: &@)C #$D "Z"0D S') < >@&Y) )F*&G )F,) )F*: ;(,*+ ;,& ,>>=%:: @'= $=@O(%+ @. >*:)*&B'*:F*&B O%(*%. .=@+ *+,B*&*&B ,: F,&>*(I ,: c;T*&& +*BF) )F*&G1 :*&;% :,I*&B )F,) *+,B*&*&B *: ,& ,;)*@& :%%+: )@ ;@&.(,)% ,//#/143 #+,5#.#.5  M*)F -%.&/01-/#23 #+,5#.#.5 D VYQF,'BF&%::I #65551 ;FD ""3"Z0 ,(:@ $=%:%&): , ),]@&@+I ,&> ,&,(I:*: @. *+,B*&,)*@& )F,) *: M%(( M@=)F ;@&:*>%=*&BD   Z W% :F@'(> ,(:@ ,:G MFI )F% $=@O(%+ F%=% +,I O% :@ )=*;GI1 ,&> ,& ,&:M%= )@ )F*: H'%:)*@& *: %&;@>%> *& )F% $F=,:% A+,G% O%(*%J%CK )F,) $F=,:% @&(I +,G%: :%&:% *. )F% *+,B*&*&B: '&>%=(I*&B $=%)%&:% :F,=% +,&I @. )F% ;F,=,;)%=*:)*;: @. O%(*%.:D X&> *. *+,B*&*&B: :F,=% +,&I @. )F% ;F,=,;)%=*:)*;: @. O%(*%.:1 *) M*(( O% ;@==%:$@&>*&B(I )=*;G*%= )@ >*:)*&B'*:F )F% )M@ ,))*)'>%:D 8   C#'3(/#'3DE&*#74 F6/#@* 5GG2+&8" a,J*> L'+% =,*:%: @'= J%=I $=@O(%+ *& )F% >.?1#0(  K WF%=%*&1 )F%=%.@=%1 ;@&:*:): )F% >*..%=%&;% O%)M%%& :';F , .*;)*@& ,&> O%(*%.N <) (*%: &@) +%=%(I *& ,&I $%;'(*,= *>%,1 MF*;F *: ,&&%]%> )@ :';F , ;@&;%$)*@& ,: ;@++,&>: @'= ,::%&)1 ,&> MF*;F *: M,&)*&B )@ %J%=I G&@M& .*;)*@&D \@= ,: )F% +*&> F,: ,')F@=*)I @J%= ,(( *): *>%,:1 *) ;@'(> J@('&),=*(I ,&&%] )F*: $,=)*;'(,= *>%, )@ ,&I .*;)*@&1 ,&> ;@&:%H'%&)(I O% ,O(% )@ O%(*%J% MF,)%J%= *) $(%,:%:- ;@&)=,=I )@ MF,) M% .*&> OI >,*(I %]$%=*%&;%D #$D Z"0   A\*;)*@&C F%=%1 < ),G% *)1 +%,&: .*;)*@&,( *+,B*&*&BD d  L'+% ,=B'%: )F,) &@ #43,  >*:)*&B'*:F%: :';F *+,B*&*&B .=@+ O%(*%.D PF,) *:1 &@ *&)%=&,( ;@&:)*)'%&) @. )F% -%./3./& M% ),G% ,))*)'>%: )@M,=> #@= @. )F% =%$=%:%&),)*@&: *& MF*;F )F@:% ;@&)%&): ,=% %&;@>%>0 ;@&:)*)')%: )F% >*..%=%&;% O%)M%%& *+,B*&*&B ,&> O%(*%.D R@&:*>%=1 .@= %],+$(%1 )F% *>%, @. :3#.5 /013  ,&> F@M *) $(,I: @') *& )F%:% )F=%% ,))*)'>%:K #d0   \=,&G O%(*%J%: *) *: :&@M*&BD #e0   \=,&G *+,B*&%: *) *: :&@M*&BD #20   \=,&G *+,B*&%: #/ #& /013  )F,) *) *: :&@M*&BD PF% ,))*)'>% *& #20 >@%:&Y) )'=& *&)@ )F% ,))*)'>% *& #d0 U':) OI =%$=%:%&)*&B )F% *>%, @. )=')FD e  L'+% )%((: ': )F,) )F% :,+% B@%: .@= ,.( #43, K *>%, >*..%=%&;%: >@&Y) ,>> '$ )@ ,))*)'>% >*..%=%&;%:D L%=%Y: F@M F*: ,=B'+%&) M@=G:D "D   V&% ;,&&@) O%(*%J% U':) ,&I)F*&B ,) M*((D 7$=%+*:%9 6D   V&% ;,& ;@+O*&% ,&I *>%,: ,) M*((D 7$=%+*:%9 ZD   X& *>%, #  )F,) ,))%&>: ,(( O%(*%.: >*:)*&B'*:F%: O%(*%. .=@+ *+,B*&*&BD 7,::'+$)*@& M*)F ,& %I% )@ 0341-/#% 9 8D   X $%=:@& ;,& ;@+O*&% # M*)F ,&I @)F%= *>%, ,) M*((D 7.=@+ 69 dD   X $%=:@& ;,& O%(*%J% ,&I)F*&B ,) M*((D 7.=@+ Z ,&> 89 8  PF,) )F% )M@ ,))*)'>%: :F,=% ;F,=,;)%=*:)*;: *: J%=I +';F @&% @. )F% $@*&): @. )F% :*+'(,)*@&*:) $=@B=,+ .@= *+,B*&*&B:1 ,>J@;,)%> +@:) &@),O(I *& R'==*% ,&> ^,J%&:;=@.) #65560D   d  PF*: ;,& O% :%%& *& F@M F% ;@&)=,:): )F% )%=+ A.*;)*@&C M*)F :3$#37   ,&> *& F@M F% :%$,=,)%: )F@:% ,))*)'>% )%=+: .=@+ A*>%,1C MF*;F *: , M,I @. =%$=%:%&)*&BD V&% ;,& F,J% @&% @= )F% @)F%= ,))*)'>% )@ )F% :,+% *>%,D e  b%((%+,& #6555,0 ,(:@ +,G%: )F*: $@*&)D < )F*&G *) *: *+$@=),&)1 O%;,':% $%@$(% @.)%& )=I )@ %]$(,*& :3$#37   *& )%=+: @. MF,) @&% A),G%: )@ O% )='%1C %DBD1 Q;F%((%&O%=B #.@=)F;@+*&B0D S') *. )F% $=%:%&) $@*&) *: ;@==%;)1 *)Y: &@) ;(%,= F@M )F% $F=,:% A),G%: )@ O% )='%C ;@'(> >@ )F% &%%>%> %]$(,*&*&BD V. ;@'=:%1 )F% $F=,:% :@'&>: =*BF)1 O') < )F*&G )F,)Y: O%;,':% A),G%: )@ O% )='%C ,;)*J,)%: )F% ,&)%;%>%&) ;@&;%$) @. :3$#37   *& )F% (*:)%&%= ,&> )F': *: $,=:%> (*G% AO%(*%J%: )@ O% )='%DC S') ,;)*J,)*&B , ;@&;%$) *: &@) %]$(,*&*&B *)D   8 eD   R@&)=,>*;)*@&D 7.=@+ d ,&> "9 2D   Z *: .,(:%D 7.=@+ Z )F=@'BF e9 W% :,M ,O@J% )F,) )F*&G*&B @. ;@&)%&): '&>%= )F% *>%, )F%I ,=% /013  *: &@) :'..*;*%&) )@ +,G% )F%+ O%(*%J%>1 :*&;% @&% ;@'(> U':) ,: M%(( +%=%(I *+,B*&% )F%I ,=% )='%- L'+%Y: ;@&;(':*@& :*+$(I B%&%=,(*`%: )F% $@*&) )@ ,(( *>%,:D S') MF,) >@%: F% )F*&G .@((@M: .=@+ )F*:N A<) .@((@M:1 )F%=%.@=%1 )F,) )F% >*..%=%&;% O%)M%%&  7#-/#%. ,&> :3$#37   (*%: *& :@+% :%&)*+%&) @= .%%(*&B1 MF*;F *: ,&&%]%> )@ )F% (,))%=1 &@) )@ )F% .@=+%=fC 2  S%(*%. *: AJ*J*>1 (*J%(I1 .@=;*O(%1 .*=+1 :)%,>IDC Q@ L'+% %J*>%&)(I )F*&G: O%(*%.: F,J% :@+% $F%&@+%&@(@BI )F,) *+,B*&*&B: >@&Y)D S') >@%: , &3./#+3./   @=  733$#.5  =%,((I >*:)*&B'*:F O%(*%. .=@+ *+,B*&*&BN <) :%%+:1 @& )F% ;@&)=,=I1 #+,5#.#.5&  ;,& ,(:@ .*) L'+%Y: >%:;=*$)*@& @. )F% +@@)%> O%(*%. :%&)*+%&)D Q@+%@&% @O:%::%> M*)F )F% :F@M @%'0,.%&  +*BF) :)%,>*(I ,&> .@=;*O(I #@= MF,)%J%=0 *+,B*&% O%*&B .=*%&>: M*)F P@&I Q@$=,&@1 M*)F@') O%(*%J*&B *)D Q@ *)Y: F,=> )@ :%% )F,) :';F , .%%(*&B *: :'..*;*%&) .@= O%(*%.D \'=)F%=+@=%1 +,&I O%(*%.: >@&Y)  733$ .@=;%.'( @= J*J*>1 (*G% +I O%(*%. )F,) $%&: ),G% *&GD Q@ *)Y: F,=> )@ :%% )F,) :';F , .%%(*&B *: &%;%::,=ID 4  Q@ @'= $=@O(%+ *: :)*(( @$%&1 :*&;% *)Y: &@) ;(%,= )F,) L'+%Y: $F%&@+%&@(@BI M*(( :@(J% *)D S') ;@&:*>%=*&B L'+% ,((@M: $=@B=%:: *& , >*..%=%&) >*=%;)*@&K M% :%% )M@ >*+%&:*@&: @. :*+*(,=*)I O%)M%%& O%(*%. ,&> *+,B*&*&BD \*=:)1 M% >*:;@J%=%> )F,) ,.(   *>%, )F,) ;,& $,=),G% *& O%(*%. ;,& $,=),G% *& *+,B*&*&BD Q%;@&>1 *. , :%&)*+%&)g.%%(*&B ;,&Y) >*:)*&B'*:F O%(*%. .=@+ *+,B*&*&B1 )F,)Y: O%;,':% #,) (%,:) )@ , B=%,) %])%&)0 :*+*(,= :%&)*+%&):g.%%(*&B: ;,& ,))%&> O@)FD !#:#+:+)H4 ;#::#/&'@* 5GG2+&8"  a,J*> b%((%+,& #6555,0 ),G%: , >*..%=%&) ),;GD L% ,=B'%: )F,) O%(*%.: ,#+ ,/ /01/" D  /  PF%=% *:1 F% F@(>:1 , A:$%;)='+C @. M,I: )F*: ,*+ ;,& O% =%,(*`%>D X) @&% %&>1 )F% ,B%&) >%(*O%=,)%(I *&)%&>: )@ ,;;%$) @&(I )=')F:D X) )F% @)F%= %&>1 :'O3$%=:@&,( +%;F,&*:+: )F,) .@=+ ;@B&*)*J% ,))*)'>%: ;,& O% >%:*B&%> )@ I*%(> )='% @&%:D S%(*%.1 ,: @$$@:%> )@ *+,B*&*&B1 *: A=%B'(,)%>1 %*)F%= OI )F% :'OU%;)Y: *&)%&)*@&: @= OI :@+% @)F%= +%;F,&*:+:1 *& M,I: >%:*B&%> )@ %&:'=% )F,) *) *: )='%C #$D 6d80D PF*: )F%@=I .,;%: , &,)'=,( @OU%;)*@&D X=%&Y) +,&I O%(*%.: )F% $=@>';) @. )=')F3 %''%&34   $=@;%::%:1 (*G% :%(.3>%;%$)*@&N <. :@1 F@M ;,& )F%I O% :,*> )@ ,*+ ,) )=')FN b%((%+,& F,: , =%:$@&:%K F% &%J%= :,*> )F,) )F% )=')F ,*+ *: )F% %.$(   *&.('%&;% @& O%(*%. .@=+,)*@&D L% U':) :,*> )F,) ,*+ ,) )=')F *:1 .@= %J%=I O%(*%.1 %.3 %7   )F% *&.('%&;%: @& *): .@=+,)*@&D P@ ;(,=*.I1 (%)Y: >=,M , >*:)*&;)*@&K X& ,))*)'>% &/0%.5$( ,*+: ,) )=')F *.. %.$(   )=')F3)=,;G*&B +%;F,&*:+: .@=+ ,&> =%J*:% *)D 2  $D Z"D X(( =%.%=%&;%: )@ )F% >.?1#0(   ,=% )@ )F% L,;G%)) Q%;@&> %>*)*@&D 4  Q%% Q)=@'> #"/4"1 $$D e/ ..D0 .@= +@=% *&3>%$)F >*:;'::*@& @. )F*: %],;) *::'%D /  [@)% )F,) QF,F ,&> b%((%+,& #655d0 >%$,=) .=@+ b%((%+,&Y: #6555,0 J*%M *& *+$@=),&) M,I:D [%J%=)F%(%::1 < .@;': @& b%((%+,& #6555,0 F%=% .@= )F=%% =%,:@&:K )F% $@:*)*@& *& )F,) $*%;% *: )F%@=%)*;,((I )%+$)*&B- *): =%.'),)*@& *: *&:)=';)*J%- ,&> *) F,: O%%& *&.('%&)*,(D   d X& ,))*)'>% A3,8$(   ,*+: ,) )=')F *.. &%+3 )=')F3)=,;G*&B +%;F,&*:+: ,=% ,+@&B )F@:% )F,) .@=+ ,&> =%J*:% *)D "5  b%((%+,&Y: ':% @. A,*+: ,) )=')FC ;@==%:$@&>: )@ )F% M%,G :%&:%1 :@ :%(.3>%;%$)*@& *:&Y) , ;@'&)%=%],+$(%1 :*&;% *) :%%+: )F,) %J%& *& :%(.3>%;%$)*@& )F%=% *: , )%,:$@@& @. %J*>%&;% *& )F% ,B%&)Y: +*&> )F,) ;@F%=%: M*)F )F% :%(.3>%;%$)*J% O%(*%.D ""  S') &@M b%((%+,& F,: ,&@)F%= $=@O(%+K &%+3 #+,5#.#.5& ,$&% A3,8$( ,#+ ,/ /01/" D ^%;,(( .=@+ ?,=) < )F,) ;@&:)=';)*J% *+,B*&*&B (,=B%(I ':%: *&.%=%&)*,( $=@;%::%: )F,) B@J%=& )F@'BF) ,O@') =%,(*)ID Q@ , B*J%& *+,B*&*&B M*(( (*G%(I F,J% &%+3 +%;F,&*:+: ,*+%> ,) )=')F *& *): %)*@(@BID PF':1 )@ :,I O%(*%.: :)=@&B(I ,*+ ,) )=')F *: .,(:%D P@ :,I O%(*%.: M%,G(I ,*+ ,) )=')F >@%:&Y) >*:)*&B'*:F O%(*%. .=@+ *+,B*&*&B1 :*&;% +,&I *+,B*&*&B: M%,G(I ,*+ ,) )=')F )@@D "6  b%((%+,&Y: ,$$=@,;F1 *) :%%+:1 M@&Y) M@=GD S') )F@'BF F*: ,))%+$) .,*(:1 *) O@@:): )F% (%::@& M%YJ% O%%& M@=G*&B @&D R=*)*H'*&B b%((%+,& =%J%,(: +@=% :'$$@=) .@= )F% J*%M )F,) *+,B*&*&B: :F,=% +,&I @. )F% ;F,=,;)%=*:)*;: @. O%(*%.K +,&I #*. &@) +@:)0 *+,B*&*&B: ,$$%,= )@ F,J% , M%,G )=')F ,*+ #*& )F% =%(%J,&) :%&:%0 ,: M%((D "Z  .',#2#'3(&: 5GG2+&8"#*4 C('"&>&>6 &'7 I3"#2*  W%YJ% :%%& )F,) $=@+*&%&) :%&)*+%&)3O,:%> ,&> )=')F3,*+ ,$$=@,;F%: F,J% >*..*;'()*%:D X&@)F%= ,$$=@,;F *: )@ :,I O%(*%.: ,&> *+,B*&*&B: F,J% >*..%=%&) *&.%=%&)*,( $=@$%=)*%:D Q*&F,O,O'1 .@= %],+$(%1 :'BB%:): )F,) AfO%(*%.: :),&> *& $,=)*;'(,= *&.%=%&)*,( =%(,)*@&: )@ @&% ,&@)F%=_*. @&% O%(*%J%: )F,) $ ,&> O%(*%J%: )F,) *. $ )F%& H1 ,&> =%.(%;): @& )F%:% $=@$@:*)*@&:1 @&% )I$*;,((I .@=+: )F% O%(*%. )F,) HC #$D "e50D PF@'BF *) :@'&>: $=@+*:*&B1 )F*: J%=:*@& @. )F% *&.%=%&)*,( ,$$=@,;F M@&Y) M@=GD h%)Y: ;@&:*>%= )F% *::'% .@=+,((ID h%) RXiiiiiii O% ,&I ;@B&*)*J% ,))*)'>%D R@&:*>%= @-"3+, B # B .@= *&.%=%&;%0K <. @&% F,: RXiiiiiii )F,)  '  ,&> RXiiiiiii )F,) *.  '  )F%& ? 1 ,&> =%.(%;): @& )F%:%1 @&% )I$*;,((I .@=+: RXiiiiiii )F,) ? D PF*: :;F%+, +,G%: ;@&.@=+*)I )@ +%41& '%.3.& , $,=)*,( ;F,=,;)%=*`,)*@& @. , ;@B&*)*J% ,))*)'>%D Q*&F,O,O' :%%+: )@ F@(> )F,) )F*: :;F%+, ;F,=,;)%=*`%: O%(*%.1 ,: @$$@:%> )@ *+,B*&*&BD S') )F,)Y: &@) =*BF)1 ,: F% ,>+*):K A*. < *+,B*&% )F,) +I F@':% *: @& .*=%1 ,&> *+,B*&% )F,) *. +I F@':% *: @& .*=% <Y+ *& >,&B%=1 <Y(( O% *+,B*&*&B )F,) "5  PF% $F=,:% A,*+ ,) )=')FC *: ':%> *& , &'+O%= @. M,I: *& )F% (*)%=,)'=%D < >@&Y) M*:F )@ ,>>=%:: ,(( @. )F%+D < *&)=@>';% )F*: >*:)*&;)*@& )@ F%($ >*:;':: )F% +%=*): :$%;*.*;,((I @. b%((%+,&Y: $@:*)*@&D   ""  \'=)F%=+@=%1 *& ;,:%: MF%=% )F% AO%(*%.C ;@F%=%: M*)F .% %J*>%&;%1 ,: *& ;%=),*& >%(':*@&:1 *) *: ,(:@ '&;(%,= )@ MF,) %])%&) *) *: =*BF) )@ ;@&;%*J% @. *) ,: , B%&'*&% O%(*%.D PF%=% *: H'*)% , (*)%=,)'=% @& )F*: J%=I )@$*;- :%% EB,& #655/0 .@= , ':%.'( B,)%M,I *&)@ *)D   "6  ?%=F,$: )F%=% *: &%+3  (%J%( @. ,*+*&B ,) )F% )=')F *& O%)M%%& M%,G ,&> :)=@&B )F,) *: :)=@&B %&@'BF )@ ='(% @') *+,B*&*&B: O') :)*(( M%,G %&@'BF )@ ,((@M :%(.3>%;%$)*J% O%(*%.: *&)@ )F% ;,)%B@=I @. :3$#37  D < >@'O) , :$%;*.*;,)*@& @. :';F , (%J%( ;,& O% .@'&>1 O') <Y> (@J% )@ :%% ,& ,))%+$)D "Z  ^%;,(( %:$%;*,((I )F% W%:*O%=B ,&> T@@>:)%*& #655/0 %]$%=*+%&):1 >*:;'::%> *& ?,=) <1 MF*;F J%=I +';F F%($ %:),O(*:F )F% *>%, )F,) +,&I *+,B*&*&B: F,J% ,) (%,:) , M%,G )=')F ,*+D
Related Search
Similar documents
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks